Report "Between shore and ship"

Between shore and ship: mathematical-didactic education research in the Netherlands

In the autumn of 2012, the Board of PWN set up an Education Research Committee (PWN-OOC) to carry out an inventory of the state of mathematical-didactic education research in the Netherlands, of funds and resources for mathematical-didactic education research, and of research topics for the future, as well as to propose further steps to promote mathematical-didactic education research in the Netherlands.

PWN-OOC has limited itself to mathematics in secondary education and has not involved educational research into mathematics or primary or higher education. To answer the question about the state of mathematical-didactic research, PWN-OOC conducted an email survey among universities and conducted a more informal inventory in HBO. The survey's questions focus on permanent formation, projects and financing, and output (2009-June 2013 period). The funding landscape has been mapped out by own input and interviews. The research themes have been inventoried by studying, inter alia, input from the National Institute of Education Research and the Education Research Programme Board, and in addition, to ask experts and stakeholders. The results on the state of mathematical-didactic educational research can be summarised as follows:

  • In the Netherlands, 7.0 FTE was available for mathematical-didactic education research at the university's June 2013 level, of which 4.6 FTE temporary staff and 2.4 FTE permanent staff. Of the 2.4 permanent staff, 0.3 FTE HGL and 0.4 FTE UHD. There is no formation within the colleges for mathematical-didactic educational research.
  • The research output in this field since 2009 includes 272 publications, of which 105 are classified as subject publications and the other scientific articles, including 24 ISI articles (in journals on the Thomson Reuters list).
  • The volume of ongoing research projects at the reference date is 7.0 FTE.

The results in terms of funding possibilities are that acquiring resources for mathematical-didactic research is extremely difficult. Both at national and international level, and both in the public and private sectors, resources appear to be declining. In the distribution of scarce resources, education research does not seem to be at the forefront in general. For mathematical-didactic research in particular, it falls between shore and ship: for beta funds, the research is not precise enough, while for educational sources it is too specific in its mathematical nature and too little general education.

With regard to the research themes for the future, the themes have been distinguished in relation to mathematical content (21st century skills, curricular coherence, and the language of mathematics), themed topics on learning (from statistics, from mathematical reasoning, with educational software, motivation) and on teaching (ICT use, professionalisation of teachers, mathematical thinking activities, excellence and differentiation, training of mathematics teachers).

On the basis of these findings, the Committee concludes that the state of the mathematical-didactic education research in the Netherlands is worrying. The available formation at the various universities is too limited. Especially the very small fixed senior formation, for example in the form of chairs in the didactics of mathematics, gives rise to great concern. Although research output, both at scientific level and in the form of practical professional publications, is respectable, it is to be feared that it will decrease in the coming years due to the reduced available research formation. The number of ongoing research projects is small, while the need for nutrition and informed information from the educational field is high. In addition, resources for mathematical-didactic education research are under pressure. The committee makes the following recommendations for follow-up steps to promote mathematical-didactic education research in the Netherlands.

  1. Chairs of mathematics. PWN consults with beta faculties in the Netherlands to promote the establishment of mathematics teaching chairs. In order to ensure a distribution across the Netherlands and across different types of universities, a chair at a general university and a technical university is initially envisaged. Reinforcement of the mathematical-didactic community in the form of
    UHD formation stimulated.
  2. Lectorates mathematics. PWN supports initiatives to promote the establishment of mathematics teaching teachers' training and applications for PhD positions in mathematical-didactic research by teachers of HBO teacher training.
  3. Research proposals. PWN acts as a co-seeker of research proposals in the field of mathematics teaching, as a mediator of exact funds for scientific research and as a representative of mathematics in general educational funds.
  4. Policy and governance. PWN is active as a political lobbyist for the matter of mathematical-didactic education research as a necessary nutrition of education policy and teacher training. Contacts with e.g. educational spokesmen from chamber groups could shape this.
  5. Committee on Education. PWN establishes a standing committee on education research, which supports the board and advises on the above actions.

Download here the full report

EnglishenEnglishEnglish